Amid an ongoing debate over proposed judicial reforms in Israel, accompanied by significant protests, questions surrounding the preservation of democracy have come to the forefront. Drawing parallels to similar debates in Poland, Hungary, and Turkey, concerns about potential impacts on democratic principles and artistic freedom have been raised.
This panel session will delve into the intricate interplay between government interference, cultural spheres, and artistic expression in these countries. By examining historical and contemporary contexts, our panel seeks to illuminate the experiences of artists and cultural institutions within these regions. We will explore the challenges they face when navigating political dynamics that threaten artistic autonomy and democratic norms. By drawing on lessons from successful as well as unsuccessful responses, we aim to enrich our understanding of how the art and culture communities have reacted to governmental overreach and democratic erosion.
As cultural practitioners play a pivotal role in shaping societies, our panel discussion aspires to not only shed light on challenges but also offer valuable insights into potential pathways for preserving artistic integrity, strengthening democracy, and promoting open dialogue within complex political environments.
Battered But Not Yet Completely Silenced (Türkiye)
Zeyno PekünlüThe political scene in Turkey has been utterly unpredictable and unstable during the last decade. Accordingly, the very nature of the political field has kept alive the tension between the fear of a regime change towards even more authoritarian forms and the persistent hope to turn the tide via elections or referendums. In the lack of state support for arts, almost all the major art institutions are founded and run by wealthy business dynasties which allows the establishment of contemporary art production seemingly independent from the ideological and material domination of the state. The relationship between the state, institutions, and cultural workers is uniquely tense as a result of this structure. The talk will focus on particular cases of friction and conflict amongst these different actors in the last decade, examining how the field underwent complex alliances and tried varied strategies when they were directly or indirectly targeted.
Dr. Zeyno Pekünlü is an artist based in Istanbul and currently running the Istanbul Biennial Research and Production Program and the Istanbul Cell of Fellowship for Situated Practice organized by BAK Utrecht. Together with Köken Ergun, she is co-founder of KIRIK, an initiative for people and topics in the cracks. She is part of the editorial board of the e-journal Red Thread and member of IRI (Institute of Radical Imagination).
Caution, Hegemony is under Construction! The Cultural Infrastructure of the Orbán-regime of Hungary from Within (Hungary)
Kristóf NagyHungary’s “illiberalism” is frequently in the news and juxtaposed with other authoritarian regimes. However, we still know little about its global context and everyday practices. In my lecture, instead of treating cultural politics and policies as a freak show, I focus on how the nationalist reshaping of Hungarian cultural production is part of a global rise of state capitalism. Based on my ethnographic fieldwork at a Hungarian cultural flagship institution, I stress that the everyday transformation of cultural infrastructure is just as significant as the more obvious takeover of cultural institutions.
Kristóf Nagy is a Budapest-based researcher of art, culture, and society. Previously he was trained at The Courtauld Institute of Art, and now he is finishing his Ph.D. at the Central European University. His dissertation project examines the cultural politics of the Orbán regime, via an ethnography of the Hungarian Academy of Arts. He serves as an editor of the social theory journal Fordulat, and is a member of the Helyzet Working Group for Public Sociology. He is also affiliated with the Central European Research Institute for Art History and the Eötvös Loránd University.
Eight years. Postartistic practices in Poland between 2015 and 2023 (Poland)
Dr. Kuba SzrederIn my presentation I will focus on postartistic practices that have emerged in Poland since 2015, in response to rising authoritarianism. I will discuss a host of activities – such as antifascist year, demonstrations of paintings, or ecofeminist groupings – as strange tools used and reused collectively in the times of crisis. Paraphrasing Jerzy Ludwiński, a Polish theoretician of conceptual art, they may not resemble art proper, but they offer us greater possibilities, combining conceptual density with political edge. I will conclude my address by reflecting upon impact of those transformations on artistic institutions and systems of cultural production at large.
Dr. Kuba Szreder is a researcher, curator, and lecturer at the Academy of Fine Art in Warsaw. He cooperates with artistic unions, consortia of postartistic practitioners, clusters of art-researchers, art collectives and artistic institutions in Poland, UK, and other European countries. Editor and author of books and texts on the political economy of global artistic circulation, art strikes, artistic self-organization in the expanded field, and the use value of art. His most recent book The ABC of the projectariat. Living and working in a precarious art world, was published by the Whitworth Museum and Manchester University Press in December 2021.